What makes a movie feminist?
Friday, August 27th, 2004When I saw Girlfight, whenever it came out, I remember hearing about how it was such! a! feminist! movie!
It wasn’t. It was like 30 zillion of the 80s movies where the girl wants to be a dancer and falls in love with some guy and he makes her choose between dance and him and she chooses her job. Except this time it was about boxing, and I think they were Hispanic. But it’s the same difference. Feminist movies, apparently, mean movies with guys who are assholes, and where you choose a job over a guy because you absolutely can’t have both because he won’t let you.
I also saw The Prince & Me. (I’m a huge fan of Julia Stiles.) Spoiled prince goes to the US, falls in love with a farmer’s daughter who’s planning to go to med school, grows up, she learns to be herself, etc etc. She finds out he’s a prince, she’s mad, he goes back to become king, she flies to Denmark to be with him, they get engaged. Blah blah blah. All the princessy stuff happens — and I like that sort of stuff — and then she realises she’s given up who she is to become a princess, so she goes back home.
They actually shot two endings. In one she doesn’t see him again. In the other, he appears at her graduation (from undergrad) and says he loves her, he’ll wait for her to finish med school and do whatever else she wants to do. (She wanted to do humanitarian work, which would presumably be doable if you’ve got a monarchy behind you.)
The movie ended with the second ending. In watching one of the special features, the director said that she felt people would feel cheated if the relationship never happened. I was disappointed. That’s not the right reason to have chosen that ending (which I think is the right ending). The reason is because you don’t always need to make a choice between your job and having a relationship. The reason is because there are many guys out there who want you to be happy in a job, even if it takes you away from them some, who are willing to put off their wants for yours. You can make a number of complaints about this movie — as about the other — but in the end, it seems a much more feminist movie than Girlfight.