This morning, I went to shul, for the first time in many years. I have long been disenchanted with the options here, and today has not re-enchanted me. I grew up in a compromise synagogue, a reconstructionist shul with a wannabe-conservative (or maybe conservadox) rabbi. Eventually my family drifted to the reform one here, the one my mother grew up in, and it’s where I went today, for the first day of Rosh Hashana.
And I know it’s not a joyous holiday, it’s solemn, but the songs were like dirges. The Sh’ma should not be funereal. (On the plus side: they were all so slow I could read the Hebrew (if I didn’t know the words) and sing along.) And they didn’t sing the Mourner’s Kaddish, which I like to hear sung. (It was just chanted.) It’s hard to make changes to the tunes you know, but especially hard when the songs make you think, hey, today’s a good day to slit my wrists! Awesome! And I felt that there wasn’t focus on the new year aspect of it — the sermon was about how time alone doesn’t heal, and though I agree with that, it seemed somehow off. (Especially off: he talked about the recent war, but not the shooting at the school across the street.) I can’t define why. I know it’s about atonement, but there was no talk of atonement. There was no talk of renewal, either, of a fresh start, which is what I think more of: you are sorry for what you did, you make amends to those you hurt (this is an integral thing), and you get to try again. I know you can’t talk about the same thing every year, and I know, also, that there are only a few services a year that the rabbi has to reach everyone — but still, something felt missing here, today. The synagogue fills up with people and then empties out speedily — there’s no feeling of community. I’m debating trying again tomorrow, when it should be emptier, and also considering going for Sukkot, or Simchat Torah, not just Yom Kippur, but . . . I don’t know. I am always frustrated by the Jewish community here, and I know I’m not the only one, but I also know I am far to lazy to do anything but be frustrated.
Also, the people who blew the shofar (which isn’t easy) were really, really, really terrible.